CAT5E and CAT6E Comparison - CCTVHelp.com Discussion Board
 
       

Go Back   CCTVHelp.com Discussion Board > Announcements, News, and Reviews > Reviews

Reviews Our techs review the latest and greatest products in the CCTV industry

 
 
Review Tools Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
CAT5E and CAT6E Comparison CAT5E and CAT6E Comparison
Advantages and Disadvantages
LevonP
01-16-2008
Attachments
Why do I need all the bandwidth of category 6e? As far as I know, there is no application today that requires 200 MHz of bandwidth.

Bandwidth precedes data rates just as highways come before traffic. Doubling the bandwidth is like adding twice the number of lanes on a highway. The trends of the past and the predictions for the future indicate that data rates have been doubling every 18 months. Current applications running at 1 Gb/s are really pushing the limits of category 5e cabling. As streaming media applications such as video and multi-media become commonplace, the demands for faster data rates will increase and spawn new applications that will benefit from the higher bandwidth offered by category 6e. This is exactly what happened in the early 90’s when the higher bandwidth of category 5 cabling compared to category 3 caused most LAN applications to choose the better media to allow simpler, cost effective, higher speed LAN applications, such as 100BASE-TX. Note: Bandwidth is defined as the highest frequency up to which positive power sum ACR (Attenuation to Crosstalk Ratio) is greater than zero.

What is the general difference between category 5e and category 6e?

The general difference between category 5e and category 6e is in the transmission performance, and extension of the available bandwidth from 100 MHz for category 5e to 200 MHz for category 6e. This includes better insertion loss, near end crosstalk (NEXT), return loss, and equal level far end crosstalk (ELFEXT). These improvements provide a higher signal-to-noise ratio, allowing higher reliability for current applications and higher data rates for future applications.

Will category 6e supersede category 5e?

Yes, analyst predictions and independent polls indicate that 80 to 90 percent of all new installations will be cabled with category 6e. The fact that category 6e link and channel requirements are backward compatible to category 5e makes it very easy for customers to choose category 6e and supersede category 5e in their networks. Applications that worked over category 5e will work over category 6e.

What does category 6e do for my current network vs. category 5e?

Because of its improved transmission performance and superior immunity from external noise, systems operating over category 6e cabling will have fewer errors vs. category 5e for current applications. This means fewer re-transmissions of lost or corrupted data packets under certain conditions, which translates into higher reliability for category 6e networks compared to category 5e networks.

When should I recommend or install category 6e vs. category 5e?

From a future proofing perspective, it is always better to install the best cabling available. This is because it is so difficult to replace cabling inside walls, in ducts under floors and other difficult places to access. The rationale is that cabling will last at least 10 years and will support at least four to five generations of equipment during that time. If future equipment running at much higher data rates requires better cabling, it will be very expensive to pull out category 5e cabling at a later time to install category 6e cabling. So why not do it for a premium of about 20 percent over category 5e on an installed basis?

What is the shortest link that the standard will allow?

There is no short length limit. The standard is intended to work for all lengths up to 100 meters. There is a guideline in ANSI/TIA/EIA-568-B.1 that says the consolidation point should be located at least 15 meters away from the telecommunications room to reduce the effect of connectors in close proximity. This recommendation is based upon worst-case performance calculations for short links with four mated connections in the channel.

What is a “tuned” system between cable and hardware? Is this really needed if product meets the standard?

The word “tuned” has been used by several manufacturers to describe products that deliver headroom to the category 6e standard. This is outside the scope of the category 6e standard. The component requirements of the standard have been carefully designed and analyzed to assure channel compliance and electrical/ mechanical interoperability.

What is impedance matching between cable and hardware? Is this really needed if product meets the standard?

The standard has no impedance matching requirements. These are addressed by having return loss requirements for cables, connectors, and patch cords.

Is there a use for category 6e in the residential market?

Yes, category 6e will be very effective in the residential market to support higher Internet access speeds while facilitating the more stringent Class B EMC requirements (see also the entire FCC Rules and Regulations, Title 47, Part 15). The better balance of category 6e will make it easier to meet the residential EMC requirements compared to category 5e cabling. Also, the growth of streaming media applications to the home will increase the need for higher data rates which are supported more easily and efficiently by category 6e cabling.

Why wouldn’t I skip category 6e and go straight to optical fiber?

You can certainly do that but will find that a fiber system is still very expensive. Ultimately, economics drive customer decisions, and today optical fiber together with optical transceivers is about twice as expensive as an equivalent system built using category 6e and associated copper electronics. Installation of copper cabling is more craft-friendly and can be accomplished with simple tools and techniques. Additionally, copper cabling supports the emerging Data Terminal Equipment (DTE) power standard under development by IEEE (802.3af).

What is meant by the term "Electrically Balanced"?

A simple open wire circuit consisting of two wires is considered to be a uniform, balanced transmission line. A uniform transmission line is one which has substantially identical electrical properties throughout its length, while a balanced transmission line is one whose two conductors are electrically alike and symmetrical with respect to ground and other nearby conductors.* "Electrically balanced" relates to the physical geometry and the dielectric properties of a twisted pair of conductors. If two insulated conductors are physically identical to one another in diameter, concentricity, dielectric material and are uniformly twisted with equal length of conductor, then the pair is electrically balanced with respect to its surroundings. The degree of electrical balance depends on the design and manufacturing process. Category 6e cable requires a greater degree of precision in the manufacturing process. Likewise, a category 6e connector requires a more balanced circuit design. For balanced transmission, an equal voltage of opposite polarity is applied on each conductor of a pair. The electromagnetic fields created by one conductor cancel out the electromagnetic fields created by its "balanced" companion conductor, leading to very little radiation from the balanced twisted pair transmission line. The same concept applies to external noise that is induced on each conductor of a twisted pair. A noise signal from an external source, such as radiation from a radio transmitter antenna generates an equal voltage of the same polarity, or "common mode voltage," on each conductor of a pair. The difference in voltage between conductors of a pair from this radiated signal, the "differential voltage," is effectively zero. Since the desired signal on the pair is the differential signal, the interference does not affect balanced transmission. The degree of electrical balance is determined by measuring the "differential voltage" and comparing it to the "common mode voltage" expressed in decibels (dB). This measurement is called Longitudinal Conversion Loss "LCL" in the Category 6e standard. * The ABC’s of the telephone Vol. 7

Category 6e Cable Questions

What is the difference between enhanced category 5e cable rated for 400 MHz and category 6e cable rated for 250 MHz?

Category 5e requirements are specified up to 100 MHz. Cables can be tested up to any frequency that is supported by the test equipment, but such measurements are meaningless without the context of applications and cabling standards. The category 6e standard sets minimum requirements up to 250 MHz for cables, connecting hardware, patch cords, channels and permanent links, and therefore guarantees reasonable performance that can be utilized by applications.

Why did all category 6e cable used to have a spline, and now is offered without one?

Some category 6e cable designs have a spline to increase the separation between pairs and also to maintain the pair geometry. This additional separation improves NEXT performance and allows category 6e compliance to be achieved. With advances in technology, manufacturers have found other ways of meeting category 6e requirements. The bottom line is the internal construction of the cable does not matter, so long as it meets all the transmission and physical requirements of category 6e. The standard does not dictate any particular method of cable construction.

Is there a limitation on the size of bundles one can have with category 6e? Can you have 200-300 and still pass category 6e?

There is no limit imposed by the standards on the maximum number of category 6e cables in a bundle. This is a matter for the market and the industry to determine based on practical considerations. It should be pointed out that after six or eight cables, the performance in any cable will not change significantly since the cables will be too far away to add any additional external (or alien) NEXT.

Category 6e Patch Cord Questions

Will contractors be able to make their own patch cords?

Category 6e patch cords are precision products, just like the cables and the connectors. They are best manufactured and tested in a controlled environment to ensure consistent, reliable performance. This will ensure interoperability and backward compatibility. All this supports patch cords as a factory-assembled product rather than a field-assembled product.

Do you have to use the manufacturer’s patch cords to get category 6e performance?

The category 6e standard has specifications for patch cords and connectors that are intended to assure interoperable category 6e performance. If manufacturers can demonstrate that each component meets the requirements in the standard, minimum category 6e performance will be achieved. However, manufacturers may also design their products to perform better than the minimum category 6e requirements, and in these cases compatible patch cords and connectors may lead to performance above the minimum category 6e requirements.

Category 6e Testing Questions

Why do field tester manufacturers offer many different link adapters if everyone meets the standard?

This was an interim solution while the standard was still being developed and the interoperability requirements were not yet established. It is likely that soon one or more adapters will work for testing of cabling from all vendors.

Would you get passing test results if you used a link adapter not recommended by a manufacturer?

You should expect to get passing results if both the link adapter interface and the mating jack that is part of the link are both compliant to category 6e requirements.

Category 6e Connecting Hardware Questions

Are the connectors for category 5e and category 6e different? Why are they more expensive?

Although category 6e and category 5e connectors may look alike, category 6e connectors have much better transmission performance. For example, at 100 MHz, NEXT of a category 5e connector is 43 decibels (dB), while NEXT of a category 6e connector is 54 dB. This means that a cat6e connector couples about 1/12 of the power that a cat5e connector couples from one pair to another pair. Conversely, one can say that a category 6e connector is 12 times less “noisy” compared to a category 5e connector. This vast improvement in performance was achieved with new technology, new processes, better materials and significant R&D resources, leading to higher costs for manufacturers.

What will happen if I mix and match different manufacturers' hardware together?

If the components are category 6e compliant, then you will be assured of category 6e performance.  
Author review
Performance
10%10%10%
1
Durability
10%10%10%
1
Ease of Use
10%10%10%
1
Look and Feel
10%10%10%
1
Price
10%10%10%
1
10%
 
  CCTVHelp.com Discussion Board > Announcements, News, and Reviews > Reviews


Review Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Copyright ©2008, Alternative Security Systems Ltd.
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:41 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2009, Alternative Security Systems Ltd.
Review powered by GARS LITE 1.0 ©2005-2006